Awaiting Theocratic Fireworks
Chuck Currie marked his second day guest blogging on the new blog site of the United Church of Christ by writing about…. bloggers!
The UCC is breaking new ground this week, using an official blog to provide information and commentary on the proceedings of its biennial conference, or General Synod, to church members not in attendance and to the wider public. Response to the UCC blog is already lighting up the blogosphere, which is always interested in new developments, as Currie shows. He writes: “There will be a lot more in the coming days. Stay tuned.” Indeed. And in the run up to the vote on marriage equality, and whatever the outcome, the blogopshere will light up like the Fourth of July. And the fireworks will not all be celebratory.
The UCC is poised to become the first major Christian denomination to endorse marriage equality. Even in considering such a move, it has been under attack by conservative and evangelical groups. The other day for example, UCC President John Thomas endorsed the marriage equality resolution that will be considered by the General Synod. Imediately, a UCC rightwing caucus, the Biblical Witness Fellowship, demanded Thomas’ resignation, declaring “He now now longer enjoys the credibility to continue as a religious leader of a Christian church.” One can only imagine this outfit’s reaction if the General Synod passes the marriage equality resolution.
This group is affiliated with the rightist Institute on Religion and Democracy, which has a twenty year history of external agitation and opposition to the social justice missions of the mainline denominations. IRD sponsors a network of conservative “renewal” groups that oppose the historic social justice mission and democratic traditions of the mainline churches. The annual meeting of this group is held in conjunction with the National Association of Evangelicals.
Last year, when the UCC sought to air a television ad that sought to portray the church as a place of welcome to all during the Christmas season, the Biblical Witness Fellowship joined with IRD in denouncing the ad. The tiny group is often given far more play in the media than they represent in numbers.
The UCC’s General Synod is an elected and representative body in the Congregational tradition. As the UCC points out on its web site, “Because every UCC congregation is self-governing, its [the General Synod's] resolutions speak ‘to’ but not ‘for’ the local church.” In other words, if the synod endorses same sex marriage, it does not mean that local churches are required to perform any. But if groups like the Biblical Witness Fellowship got their way, they would be seeking to create not only conservative doctrine, but to police doctrinal purity.
Religion News Service recently reported that Diana Butler Bass, a senior researcher at Virginia Theological Seminary “worried about conservatives’ attempts in the UCC and other churches to centralize authority, discipline and doctrinal standards, especially in the UCC where local congregations relish their autonomy. Such a move violates ‘the democratic impulses of American Protestantism,’ she said.”
“‘These denominations are so closely tied to the practice of democracy in this country,’ she said. ‘If they lose that kind of local meeting-house democratic impulse, it makes me wonder what’s going on in the larger culture.’”
[Crossposted at Talk to Action.]
Comment Policy
Comments are welcome with a few exceptions: Comments meant to simply offend others; that are personal attacks; that are attempts at religious conversion or chastisement; or anti-religious conversion or chastisement, or other unwelcome weirdness – will either be deleted or the commenter banned from the site. I also reserve the right not to post comments from people using fake names and / or e-mail addresses. Be willing to take responsibility for your comments.




This completely irresponsible – a number of people and groups oppossed the ad and to simply lump them together by association of the issue is absurd. Do you have any proof of any link to the BWF and IRD? I’m assuming not since you would have had a link.
Should we link al qaeda to the UCC because they were both against the war? Thankfully, the handful of people that visit this blog are smarter than that and will see your childish rhetoric.
Anonymous
2 Jul 05 at 7:31 am
Dear Anonymous Commenter,
You ask: “Do you have any proof of any link to the BWF and IRD? I’m assuming not since you would have had a link.”
I guess you must have missed the link in the key paragraph to which you take such strong exception. If you click through the word “network,” you will find the IRD-sponsored Association for Church Renewal. Then scroll down the list of member organizations in alphabetical order to the Biblical Witness Fellowship.
But just to make it really easy for you, here is the link:
http://www.ird-renew.org/site/pp.asp?c=fvKVLfMVIsG&b=356307
Frederick Clarkson
2 Jul 05 at 9:35 am
On further scrolling down the Association for Church Renewal, (thanks to our skeptical anonymous commenter) I see that there is not one but two IRD-sponsored groups operating in the UCC. The other is the The Renewal Fellowship of Chanassen, Minnesota.
Frederick Clarkson
2 Jul 05 at 10:00 am
Obviously, that “handful of people” are at least smart enough to click on all the links Mr. Clarkson provided in his post. Maybe you should start hanging out with some of them, I’m sure they’d be willing to share that knowledge.
pattyp
2 Jul 05 at 1:35 pm